Four Years After a Landmark Settlement in Rhode Island, the Fight for Inclusion Continues

Picture of Eve Hill and Gina Kline

By Eve Hill and Regina Kline

Four years ago this week, on April 8, 2014, the U.S. Department of Justice announced a landmark agreement with the state of Rhode Island to help bring people with intellectual and developmental disabilities out of segregated work settings and into typical jobs in the community at competitive pay.

It was the nation’s first statewide settlement to address the rights of people with disabilities to receive state funded services in the broader community, rather than in segregated sheltered workshops and facility-based day programs.

As members of the DOJ’s Civil Rights Division, we oversaw the investigation that led to the settlement, and witnessed first-hand how people with disabilities had been isolated and exploited in segregated factory-like settings known as sheltered workshops.

Young people with disabilities were recruited straight from school into a workshop, subsidized by taxpayers, where they kept working in segregation for decades. Students were often denied meaningful opportunities to participate in integrated alternatives, such as integrated transition work placements and work-based learning experiences. This put them at serious risk of being unnecessarily placed in segregated sheltered workshops and facility-based day programs.

The 2014 settlement is helping to change all that, by giving thousands of people with disabilities an opportunity to work in integrated settings, at fair wages, alongside their non-disabled peers.

Many of these Rhode Islanders have been able to access and thrive in typical jobs. People like Pero, who went from working for 48 cents an hour at a workshop to making making minimum wage working at a restaurant. Or Peter, another former sheltered workshop employee who was earning about $1.50 per hour, and who went on to earn more than minimum wage working as a custodian at a hospital.

But while this settlement marked a major step forward, four years later there is still more work to be done. Across the country, an estimated 500,000 disabled workers continue to work in sheltered workshops, where they perform manual labor, typically in exchange for subminimum wages.

These workers quite often have the ability and desire to work in safer, more mainstream jobs for decent pay, but they have been shunted away into sheltered workshops that pay as little as 22 cents per hour.

As we saw in Rhode Island, these sheltered workshops are often embedded in state and local government systems that operate in violation of recent court rulings and federal regulations that prohibit the unjustified isolation and segregation of people with disabilities.

This must change.

State and local governments must take affirmative steps to ensure that students with disabilities have opportunities to make informed choices, have access to individualized job transition services, and have the necessary supports after leaving school.

Businesses also have a role to play by hiring people with disabilities as part of their mainstream workforces, and ridding their supply chains of contractors that segregate and exploit them.

The good news is that the changing legal landscape – including recent Supreme Court decisions and changes to the enforcement of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA) – has actually made it easier than ever for organizations to achieve real inclusion of people with intellectual and developmental disabilities. 

Instead of being onerous, these laws and regulations work in tandem – creating a complementary system of supports that can help young people with disabilities transition from school into rewarding jobs in their communities.

The Rhode Island settlement should serve as a model for other states, and a milestone in a journey that still continues – away from isolation and exclusion, and towards greater access and opportunity for all.

Authored by

Eve Hill Partner